Jump to any asset
Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF vs Schwab U.S. Broad Market ETF
VS
Comparative Analysis
SCHB wins this head-to-head comparison against VTI, primarily due to its slightly better risk-adjusted performance and lower net assets, suggesting greater flexibility. While both ETFs track broad U.S. equity markets with identical expense ratios and similar sector exposures, SCHB's marginally superior trailing returns over longer periods and its more concentrated net assets offer a subtle advantage. VTI, despite its larger asset base, shows a slight underperformance relative to its category in the 1-year timeframe, whereas SCHB maintains parity. The decision hinges on SCHB's ability to deliver comparable market exposure with potentially greater agility and a slightly more favorable long-term return profile relative to its peers. Both VTI and SCHB are large-cap blend ETFs from reputable fund families, Vanguard and Schwab ETFs, respectively. They offer highly diversified exposure to the U.S. stock market, with Technology and Financial Services being their largest sector allocations. Their expense ratios are identical at 0.03%, meaning an investor would pay $30 per $10,000 invested annually for either fund. This parity in cost and broad market exposure makes the choice dependent on finer details of performance and asset management.
Key Differentiator
The key differentiator between VTI and SCHB lies in their scale and potentially their agility. VTI, with its massive net assets of over $2.3 trillion, represents the pinnacle of broad U.S. equity market tracking, offering unparalleled diversification and investor confidence. SCHB, while substantial at $44.6 billion, is considerably smaller, which could translate to slightly more flexibility for its fund managers in navigating market dynamics or rebalancing. Although their expense ratios and sector exposures are virtually identical, SCHB's slightly better trailing returns over the 5 and 10-year periods, coupled with its smaller asset base, suggests a subtle edge in performance efficiency and potential for nimbler execution in a dynamic market.
Joint Outlook
The outlook for both VTI and SCHB is largely tied to the performance of the broader U.S. equity market, which is currently showing mixed signals. Short-term technical indicators suggest a bearish bias, with both ETFs trading below their 50-day and 20-day moving averages and exhibiting neutral to slightly negative momentum. A potential scenario involves a continuation of this short-term weakness, possibly driven by macroeconomic concerns or sector-specific headwinds, leading to further price declines towards their 200-day moving averages. However, the long-term outlook remains positive, supported by their positions above the 200-day moving averages and the historical resilience of the U.S. stock market. A bullish scenario would see a rebound from current levels, driven by positive economic data, easing inflation, or technological advancements, pushing both ETFs towards new 52-week highs. SCHB's slightly better historical performance and smaller asset base might allow it to capture upside more efficiently in a strong bull market, while VTI's massive scale offers unparalleled stability and diversification.
Price Analysis Comparison
Asset Metrics
| Metric | VTI | SCHB |
|---|---|---|
| 52 Week Range | $310.40 - $385.12 | $24.28 - $30.15 |
| Prev. Close | $375.56 | $29.40 |
| Market Cap | 725.71B | N/A |
| 24h Volume | 3.31M | 5.90M |
Valuation is not directly applicable to broad market ETFs like VTI and SCHB, as they represent a basket of underlying stocks rather than a single entity with a P/E ratio. However, their performance metrics can be viewed as a proxy for the market's collective valuation. Both ETFs are currently trading below their 50-day moving averages (VTI at $373.24 vs. $374.34, SCHB at $29.23 vs. $29.31), indicating a short-term bearish sentiment or consolidation. VTI is also below its 20-day exponential moving average, suggesting recent downward price pressure. SCHB's price is closer to its 52-week high ($29.23 vs. $30.15) than VTI ($373.24 vs. $385.12), implying SCHB has experienced a more significant pullback from its peak. The RSI for both is in neutral territory (VTI 43.4, SCHB 43.94), suggesting neither is overbought or oversold, but both are leaning towards a weaker momentum. Examining their positions relative to their 52-week lows provides further context. VTI is trading at $373.24, significantly above its 52-week low of $310.40, indicating a strong overall upward trend from its lows. SCHB is at $29.23, also well above its 52-week low of $24.28. The distance from the 52-week low to the current price is proportionally larger for SCHB (approximately 20.4%) compared to VTI (approximately 20.2%), suggesting a similar magnitude of recovery from their respective lows. Both ETFs are trading above their 200-day moving averages (VTI at $352.06, SCHB at $27.55), confirming a longer-term bullish trend for the broader U.S. equity market.
Market Performance
| Metric | VTI | SCHB |
|---|---|---|
| Volatility (30D) | 12.78% | 12.58% |
| 24h Range | $372.75 - $374.54 | $29.18 - $29.31 |
| Market Strength (RSI) | 63.5 | 63.5 |
| Trend (SMA 50) | Bearish | Bearish |
Both assets exhibit similar volatility levels (~13%). Market momentum is currently Bearish for both.
Technical Indicators
| Indicator | VTI | SCHB |
|---|---|---|
| RSI (14) | 63.50 | 63.50 |
| 50-Day MA | $374.34 | $29.31 |
| 200-Day MA | $352.06 | $27.55 |
VTI is currently trading below its 50-day ($374.34) and 20-day ($377.35) moving averages, with its RSI (63.50), indicating a bearish short-term trend and neutral momentum. The MACD value of 0.35 suggests a slight bullish divergence or a potential shift from bearishness, though it remains close to zero. SCHB is also trading below its 50-day ($29.31) and 20-day ($29.54) moving averages, with an RSI (63.50), mirroring VTI's short-term bearish sentiment. Its MACD of 0.03 is very close to zero, suggesting a neutral momentum with little clear directional bias. Both ETFs are above their 200-day moving averages (VTI at $352.06, SCHB at $27.55), confirming a longer-term uptrend for the broader U.S. equity market. VTI's Stochastic reading of 5.16 and SCHB's of 6.67 indicate that both are in oversold territory on shorter timeframes, which could signal a potential bounce. However, the RSI values suggest that momentum is not strong in either direction currently. The CCI for both is significantly negative (VTI -190.47, SCHB -191.73), reinforcing the idea of a short-term downtrend or significant selling pressure from recent highs.
AI Analyst Sentiment
Technical rating — based on current price action versus moving averages and momentum. This measures short-term chart trend, not analyst opinion or company fundamentals.
VTI
Technical Score: 75/100
SCHB
Technical Score: 75/100
As broad-market ETFs, VTI and SCHB do not have analyst ratings or median price targets. Sentiment must be inferred from price action and technical indicators. Both ETFs are currently trading below their key short-term moving averages (50-day and 20-day), suggesting a prevailing bearish sentiment in the immediate market outlook. The RSI values for both are in the low 40s, indicating a lack of strong buying interest and a leaning towards caution among investors. The negative CCI readings further support this sentiment, pointing to prevailing downward pressure. Despite these short-term bearish signals, the fact that both ETFs remain well above their 200-day moving averages indicates a more positive underlying long-term sentiment for the U.S. equity market as a whole.
Risk Stratification
| Metric | VTI | SCHB |
|---|---|---|
| Sharpe Ratio | 0.71 | 0.72 |
The primary risk for both VTI and SCHB is market-wide downturns, as they are designed to track the overall U.S. stock market. Given their significant exposure to the Technology sector (over 35%), any adverse developments impacting major tech companies, such as regulatory changes, increased competition, or slowing innovation, could disproportionately affect their performance. VTI's larger net assets of over $2.3 trillion, while indicating stability and broad investor trust, could also mean less agility in reacting to rapid market shifts compared to SCHB's $44.6 billion in net assets. A significant economic recession or a sharp rise in interest rates could lead to substantial declines in the value of the underlying equities held by both ETFs. SCHB's slightly lower net assets might present a marginal risk if market liquidity were to become severely constrained, though this is unlikely for such a large ETF. However, this smaller asset base could also imply greater flexibility for the fund manager to adapt to market conditions or rebalance holdings more efficiently. Both ETFs share the risk of sector concentration, particularly in technology, which could lead to higher volatility than a more evenly distributed portfolio. Furthermore, geopolitical events or unexpected inflation spikes could negatively impact the broader equity market and, consequently, the performance of both VTI and SCHB.
Comparative ProTips
- Consider SCHB for its marginally better long-term performance and potential for greater management agility due to its smaller asset base.
- Monitor the Technology sector's performance closely, as it represents a significant portion of both ETFs' holdings and can drive volatility.
- Given the identical expense ratios and similar broad market exposure, the choice between VTI and SCHB may come down to subtle differences in tracking or management style over time.
Monte Carlo Projection (10yr)
Actionable Trade Plans
Compare entry, exit, and risk management levels for both assets
Select Your Trade Bias
Risk Tolerance
Conservative
3%
Aggressive
Portfolio Value
$
✎
Position Size: $200 - $300 per asset
VTI
Current: $373.24
ENTRY ZONES
Conservative
$354.58
Aggressive
$373.24
RISK MANAGEMENT
STOP LOSS
$343.94
MAX LOSS
-3%
Volatility-Adjusted Stop Loss
Calculated based on volatility and technical support levels.
Profit Targets (Based on Conservative)
+5%
$372.31
+10%
$390.04
+15%
$407.76
SCHB
Current: $29.23
ENTRY ZONES
Conservative
$27.77
Aggressive
$29.23
RISK MANAGEMENT
STOP LOSS
$26.94
MAX LOSS
-3%
Volatility-Adjusted Stop Loss
Calculated based on volatility and technical support levels.
Profit Targets (Based on Conservative)
+5%
$29.16
+10%
$30.55
+15%
$31.93
Calculate Your Trade
Disclaimer
This comparison involves assets with varying risk profiles. The content is for educational purposes only. Identifying the stronger asset is based on relative strength (RS) and technical convergence. Past correlation does not guarantee future lockstep movement. Trading involves risk of loss. Note: The AI favored SCHB based on risk profile. This is valid for the specified timeframe only.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which ETF is a better buy, VTI or SCHB?+
SCHB is marginally the better buy due to its slightly superior long-term trailing returns and potentially greater management agility stemming from its smaller net asset base, despite identical expense ratios and sector exposures.
What are the key risks for VTI vs SCHB?+
Both ETFs face market-wide downturns and sector-specific risks due to their heavy concentration in Technology. VTI's larger asset base could imply less agility, while SCHB's smaller size presents a minimal liquidity risk in extreme scenarios.
How do VTI and SCHB compare on cost?+
Both VTI and SCHB have identical expense ratios of 0.03%, meaning an investor would pay $30 per $10,000 invested annually for either fund. This makes cost a non-factor in their comparison.
What are the sector exposures of VTI and SCHB?+
Both ETFs have very similar sector exposures, with Technology being the largest allocation (around 35-36%), followed by Financial Services (around 12-13%) and Healthcare (around 9-10%).
How do their trailing returns compare?+
SCHB shows slightly better trailing returns over the 5-year (11.75% vs 11.70%) and 10-year (14.81% vs 14.80%) periods compared to VTI. Over shorter periods like YTD and 1-year, their performance is very close, with VTI slightly underperforming its category in the 1-year timeframe while SCHB matches it.
What is the dividend yield for VTI and SCHB?+
VTI offers a dividend yield of approximately 1.04%, while SCHB offers a yield of approximately 1.03%. Both provide a similar modest income stream.
How do VTI and SCHB perform in different market conditions?+
Both ETFs are designed to track the broad U.S. equity market and thus perform similarly in most market conditions. Their current technicals suggest a short-term bearish bias, trading below key moving averages, but their long-term trend remains positive as they are above their 200-day moving averages.