Jump to any asset
849 assets, updated daily
Nucor vs Steel Dynamics
VS
Comparative Analysis
NUE wins this head-to-head comparison, primarily driven by its more attractive valuation and slightly stronger recent earnings performance. While both companies operate in the steel sector and show comparable profitability metrics, NUE's lower P/E ratio and a more consistent pattern of positive earnings surprises give it an edge. STLD, however, demonstrates higher returns on equity and assets, suggesting better capital efficiency. Technicals for both are currently subdued, indicating a period of consolidation rather than strong trending. Overall, NUE presents a more compelling value proposition at current levels, supported by a solid earnings track record and a higher median analyst target price relative to its current trading price. STLD remains a viable contender with its superior efficiency ratios, but NUE's valuation advantage is the deciding factor in this analysis.
Key Differentiator
NUE's key differentiator is its more attractive valuation coupled with a more consistent track record of positive earnings surprises. While STLD boasts slightly better capital efficiency ratios (ROE and ROA), NUE's lower P/E ratio and stronger recent earnings beats provide a more compelling entry point for value-oriented investors. The market has historically rewarded NUE's ability to exceed earnings expectations more significantly than STLD's.
Joint Outlook
The outlook for both NUE and STLD is cautiously optimistic, contingent on broader economic conditions and steel demand. NUE's valuation advantage and earnings consistency suggest it is better positioned to capitalize on any market upswing. A scenario where industrial demand remains strong and inflation moderates could see NUE outperform due to its value appeal. STLD, with its higher capital efficiency, could see significant gains if it can translate its strong revenue growth into more consistent earnings beats and overcome its current technical headwinds. In a bearish scenario, a significant economic slowdown or increased input costs could pressure both stocks. However, NUE's lower P/E might provide a degree of downside protection. The median analyst targets suggest both have similar upside potential, but NUE's current metrics make it the more defensible choice for a near-term investment, while STLD remains a strong contender for longer-term growth if its efficiency translates to sustained profitability.
Price Analysis Comparison
Valuation Metrics
| Metric | NUE | STLD |
|---|---|---|
| P/E Ratio | 19.75 | 21.18 |
| Market Cap | 56.10B | 33.49B |
| Price/Sales | 1.55 | 1.63 |
| Price/Book | 2.54 | 3.56 |
| EV/EBITDA | 10.85 | 13.93 |
| Dividend Yield | 0.90% | 0.89% |
NUE trades at a P/E ratio of 19.75, which is more attractive than STLD's P/E of 21.18. This suggests that investors are currently willing to pay less for each dollar of NUE's earnings compared to STLD. Both companies are trading significantly above their 52-week lows, with NUE at $247.25 (131.32 to 280.11) and STLD at $233.66 (134.87 to 288.74). NUE is closer to its 52-week high, trading 11.7% below it, while STLD is 19.0% below its high. This suggests STLD has more room to run if momentum shifts positively. Despite STLD being further from its 52-week high, NUE's lower P/E ratio makes it the more compelling value act. The median analyst target for NUE is $286.5, implying a 15.9% upside from its current price, whereas STLD's median target of $271 suggests a 15.9% upside as well. This parity in potential upside, combined with NUE's lower valuation multiple, tips the scales in NUE's favor from a valuation perspective.
Profitability & Efficiency
| Metric | NUE | STLD |
|---|---|---|
| Rev. Growth (Qtly) | 23.00% | 33.40% |
| Profit Margin | 7.99% | 7.83% |
| Return on Equity | 14.55% | 17.57% |
| Return on Assets | 7.32% | 7.87% |
| Debt/Equity | 30.51 | 46.92 |
STLD exhibits slightly superior profitability metrics compared to NUE. STLD's return on equity stands at 17.57%, exceeding NUE's 14.55%. Similarly, STLD's return on assets is 7.87%, marginally better than NUE's 7.32%. Both companies maintain comparable net profit margins, with NUE at 7.99% and STLD at 7.83%. These figures suggest that STLD is more efficient in generating profits from its shareholder equity and assets. While NUE's net profit margin is slightly higher, STLD's stronger returns on equity and assets indicate a more effective deployment of capital. This difference in capital efficiency is a key differentiator, though the margins are very close. For investors prioritizing capital utilization, STLD holds a slight advantage.
Earnings Reality Check
NUE
Last 5 Qs: NUE beat estimates 4x out of 5. Rose 3x after beats.
STLD
Last 4 Qs: STLD beat estimates 3x out of 4. Rose 2x after beats.
Technical Indicators
| Indicator | NUE | STLD |
|---|---|---|
| RSI (14) | 37.86 | 41.36 |
| 50-Day MA | $255.54 | $243.81 |
| 200-Day MA | $212.79 | $215.46 |
Both NUE and STLD are currently exhibiting weak technical signals, trading below their 50-day and 200-day moving averages. NUE's price of $247.25 is below its 50-day SMA of $255.54 and its 200-day SMA of $212.79. Its RSI is at 37.86, indicating a bearish momentum, and its Stochastic is at 22.48, suggesting oversold conditions but within a downtrend. STLD's price of $233.66 is also below its 50-day SMA of $243.81 and 200-day SMA of $215.46. Its RSI is 41.36, also suggesting bearish momentum, with a Stochastic of 24.75. The MACD for NUE is -2.15 and for STLD is -2.37, both below their respective signal lines and indicating downward pressure. Neither stock shows strong signs of an immediate uptrend. NUE is slightly closer to its 50-day SMA, but both are in a similar technical position, suggesting a period of consolidation or continued weakness until key resistance levels are overcome.
AI Analyst Sentiment
Technical rating: based on current price action versus moving averages and momentum. This measures short-term chart trend, not analyst opinion or company fundamentals.
NUE
Technical Score: 59/100
STLD
Technical Score: 68/100
Analyst sentiment leans positive for both NUE and STLD, but NUE garners slightly stronger backing. NUE has a 'Strong Buy' rating from 3 analysts and 'Buy' ratings from 10, totaling 13 buy-side recommendations against 4 holds. The median analyst target price for NUE is $286.5, representing a potential upside of 15.9% from its current price. STLD has 2 'Strong Buy' ratings and 7 'Buy' ratings, with 4 holds and 1 sell, totaling 9 buy-side recommendations. STLD's median analyst target is $271, also implying a 15.9% upside from its current price. While both stocks have a healthy number of buy ratings, NUE's higher proportion of 'Strong Buy' recommendations and its slightly more favorable analyst target relative to its current price (though the percentage upside is the same) suggest a marginally more optimistic outlook from the analyst community. The presence of a sell rating for STLD, however small, also weighs slightly against it.
Note: While STLD shows stronger short-term technical momentum (Buy 68/100), the AI comparative analysis favors NUE (Hold 59/100) based on its overall trend structure, fundamentals, and risk-adjusted outlook.
Risk Stratification
| Metric | NUE | STLD |
|---|---|---|
| Beta (Volatility) | 1.88 | 1.52 |
| Sharpe Ratio | 0.56 | 0.80 |
For NUE, a primary risk is its current technical weakness, trading below key moving averages and showing bearish momentum on RSI and MACD. A slowdown in the steel industry or a broader economic downturn could negatively impact demand and pricing for NUE's products. Also, while its valuation is attractive, a failure to consistently meet earnings expectations or a deterioration in profitability could lead to a re-rating of the stock. Competition within the steel sector also poses an ongoing risk. STLD faces similar technical risks, being below its 50-day and 200-day SMAs with bearish momentum indicators. Its higher reliance on capital efficiency (ROE, ROA) means that any significant increase in input costs or pricing pressure could disproportionately affect its profitability compared to NUE. A slowdown in construction or industrial activity, key demand drivers for steel, would present a significant risk. The single sell rating among analysts also highlights a potential downside risk not fully captured by the median target.
Comparative ProTips
- Consider NUE for its superior valuation and consistent earnings beats, making it a more attractive value act.
- Monitor STLD's capital efficiency; if it can maintain its ROE and ROA while improving earnings consistency, it could offer significant upside.
- Given the current weak technicals for both stocks, investors may want to wait for clearer upward momentum signals before initiating new positions.
Monte Carlo Projection (10yr)
Actionable Trade Plans
Compare entry, exit, and risk management levels for both assets
Select Your Trade Bias
Risk Tolerance
Conservative
3%
Aggressive
Portfolio Value
$
✎
Position Size: $200 - $300 per asset
NUE
Current: $247.25
ENTRY ZONES
Conservative
$234.89
Aggressive
$247.25
RISK MANAGEMENT
STOP LOSS
$227.84
MAX LOSS
-3%
Volatility-Adjusted Stop Loss
Calculated based on volatility and technical support levels.
Profit Targets (Based on Conservative)
+5%
$246.63
+10%
$258.38
+15%
$270.12
STLD
Current: $233.66
ENTRY ZONES
Conservative
$221.98
Aggressive
$233.66
RISK MANAGEMENT
STOP LOSS
$215.32
MAX LOSS
-3%
Volatility-Adjusted Stop Loss
Calculated based on volatility and technical support levels.
Profit Targets (Based on Conservative)
+5%
$233.08
+10%
$244.17
+15%
$255.27
Calculate Your Trade
Disclaimer
This comparison involves assets with varying risk profiles. The content is for educational purposes only. Identifying the stronger asset is based on relative strength (RS) and technical convergence. Past correlation does not guarantee future lockstep movement. Trading involves risk of loss. Note: The AI favored NUE based on relative valuation. This is valid for the specified timeframe only. While STLD currently shows the stronger short-term technical score (68 vs 59), the AI favors NUE on the factors above rather than today's technical setup.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which stock, NUE or STLD, offers better valuation?+
NUE offers a better valuation with a P/E ratio of 19.75 compared to STLD's 21.18. Both stocks are trading significantly above their 52-week lows, but NUE's lower multiple makes it more attractive on a price-to-earnings basis.
How do NUE and STLD compare in terms of profitability?+
STLD shows slightly better profitability with a return on equity of 17.57% and return on assets of 7.87%, compared to NUE's 14.55% ROE and 7.32% ROA. Their net profit margins are nearly identical.
What is the current technical outlook for NUE and STLD?+
Both NUE and STLD exhibit weak technicals, trading below their 50-day and 200-day moving averages with bearish momentum indicators like RSI and MACD. Neither stock shows strong signs of an immediate uptrend.
Which stock has stronger analyst sentiment?+
Analyst sentiment is positive for both, but NUE has a slightly higher proportion of 'Strong Buy' ratings and a median target price that implies a similar upside potential as STLD, suggesting marginally stronger analyst conviction.
What are the primary risks facing NUE?+
Key risks for NUE include its current weak technical positioning, potential slowdowns in the steel industry or broader economy, and the risk of failing to meet earnings expectations or a deterioration in profitability.
What are the primary risks facing STLD?+
STLD's main risks involve its technical weakness, potential impacts from input cost increases or pricing pressures on its profitability, and a slowdown in key demand sectors like construction and industry. The presence of a sell rating also indicates potential downside.
How do their dividend yields compare?+
Both NUE and STLD offer similar dividend yields, with NUE at approximately 0.90% and STLD at approximately 0.89%. This suggests comparable income generation potential from dividends for both companies.