Jump to any asset
873 assets, updated daily
Head-to-head · ETF vs ETF
VanEck Junior Gold Miners ETF vs Global X Silver Miners ETF
vs
GDXJ vs SIL: the verdict
How GDXJ and SIL compare today, and what CleaRank Financial AI makes of it.
The verdict
CleaRank Financial AI favours
GDXJ
GDXJ
SIL
31/100
AI score
29/100
+13.3%
1-year change
+10.4%
45.3%
Volatility (30d, yearly)
41.0%
39.8
RSI (14-day)
29.6
The verdict
VanEck Junior Gold Miners ETF (GDXJ) comes out ahead on CleaRank's model, scoring 31/100 (Sell) against 29/100 (Sell) for Global X Silver Miners ETF (SIL). The scores are close, and no single factor separates them by much.
Key difference
Size is where the two funds differ most.
Outlook
SIL would need to regain its 50-day average at $90.74 and its 200-day at $91.00 to turn its downtrend.
Price, side by side
Both prices start at 0% on the first day of the period you pick, so the moves compare directly.
Rebased price
-20%-15%-10%-5%0%-17%-18%
Oct '26
0%+10%+20%+30%+40%+0.9%-1.5%
Aug '26Sep '26Oct '26
-20%-10%0%+10%-18%-20%
May '26Jun '26Jul '26Aug '26Sep '26Oct '26
0%+20%+40%+60%+80%+10%+5.3%
Nov '25Jan '26Mar '26Jun '26Aug '26Oct '26
0%+100%+200%+124%+110%
Sep '24Feb '25Jul '25Dec '25May '26Oct '26
Over 1 year: GDXJ gained 5.3% and SIL gained 10.4%, a gap of 5.1 points in SIL's favour.
Key metrics
Size and recent performance for each.
Size and market performance
GDXJ
SIL
$8.4B
Size (net assets / market cap)
$4.4B
3.7M
Volume (shares, last session)
849,500
23%
Position in 52-week range
22%
-13.0%
Price against 50-day average
-17.7%
Reading
GDXJ costs less to hold. Its expense ratio is 0.52%, while SIL's is 0.65%.
Momentum and sentiment
The indicators behind each AI score, side by side.
Indicators side by side
GDXJ
SIL
31/100
AI score
29/100
39.8
RSI (14-day)
29.6
-13.0%
Price against 50-day average
-17.7%
-13.0%
Price against 200-day average
-18.0%
Technicals
Its 14-day RSI is 33.5, in the bearish zone, with the MACD line negative. SIL is in a downtrend, trading 17.72% below its 50-day average and 17.95% below its 200-day average. Its 14-day RSI is 29.6, in the oversold zone, with the MACD line negative. SIL sits higher in its 52-week range, at 22% against 18% for GDXJ.
Sentiment
Over the past month GDXJ dropped 17.48%, but over three months it climbed 0.95%. SIL slid 18.46% in the past month and also lost ground over three months, down 1.48%.
Risk and practical tips
How much each moves, how much return each has paid for that risk, and what to watch if you hold either.
Risk measures
GDXJ
SIL
45.3%
Volatility (30d, yearly)
41.0%
0.89
Sharpe ratio
0.96
Risk
They move about the same on an average day, 2.90% for GDXJ and 2.67% for SIL. Their worst falls in the price history were 54.8% for GDXJ (August 2020 to October 2022) and 52.7% for SIL (June 2021 to October 2023).
ProTips
- For SIL, watch the 20-day EMA at $82.53 above the price and the 52-week low at $61.80 below it.
- Fees add up over time.
GDXJ vs SIL: long-term scenarios
Simulated paths from each price history. A range of outcomes, not a forecast.
Simulated growth of $10,000
$50K$100K$128K$93.7K$21.1K$18.5K
202620282030203220342036
GDXJ
SIL
$3,493
Downside, 2036 (10th)
$3,672
$21,148
Base case, 2036 (median)
$18,548
$128,035
Upside, 2036 (90th)
$93,678
In the median simulated path, $10,000 in GDXJ grows to about $21,100 and $10,000 in SIL to about $18,500 by 2036. The paths come from each asset's own historical volatility and trend; they are statistical outcomes, not forecasts.
Trade plans for both
Entry, stop and target levels from each moving average and its volatility. Educational, not advice.
Actionable Trade Plans
Select Your Trade Bias
Risk Tolerance
Conservative
3%
Aggressive
Portfolio Value
$
✎
Position Size: $200 - $300 per asset
GDXJ
Current: $103.43
ENTRY ZONES
Conservative
$105.50
Aggressive
$103.43
RISK MANAGEMENT
STOP LOSS
$108.66
MAX LOSS
-3%
Volatility-Adjusted Stop Loss
Calculated based on volatility and technical support levels.
Profit Targets (Based on Conservative)
-5% from current
$98.26
-10% from current
$93.09
-15% from current
$87.92
SIL
Current: $74.66
ENTRY ZONES
Conservative
$76.15
Aggressive
$74.66
RISK MANAGEMENT
STOP LOSS
$78.44
MAX LOSS
-3%
Volatility-Adjusted Stop Loss
Calculated based on volatility and technical support levels.
Profit Targets (Based on Conservative)
-5% from current
$70.93
-10% from current
$67.19
-15% from current
$63.46
Calculate Your Trade
Disclaimer
The content is for educational purposes only. The verdict weighs trend, valuation and risk together. Trading involves risk of loss. Note: The AI favored GDXJ based on a weighted view of valuation, momentum and risk, on today's data.
GDXJ vs SIL: questions people ask
Answered from the figures on this page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, GDXJ or SIL?+
On CleaRank's model GDXJ scores higher, 31/100 (Sell) against 29/100 (Sell) for SIL. This describes the data on this page and is not a personal recommendation.
Which is cheaper to own, GDXJ or SIL?+
GDXJ is the cheaper of the two to hold, with an expense ratio of 0.52% compared with 0.65% for SIL.
Which pays more income, GDXJ or SIL?+
Yield favors GDXJ, at 2.33% against 1.18% for SIL. Yield is the payout divided by the price, so a change in either the payout or the price moves it.
Which is riskier, GDXJ or SIL?+
They carry about the same risk on the measures we track. Average daily move: 2.90% for GDXJ, 2.67% for SIL. Worst fall in the price history: 54.8% for GDXJ, 52.7% for SIL.
Which has stronger momentum right now, GDXJ or SIL?+
The MACD line is negative for both. Readings above 70 or below 30 signal stretched momentum.
How have GDXJ and SIL performed over the past year?+
Over the 12 months to October 28, 2026, GDXJ's price rose 13.3% and SIL's rose 10.4%. These are price changes; dividends are not included.